OK, so it’s time to shift the conversation around here. What better way to execute that then with a new Top 10 ranking to prime the pump on the upcoming football season.
Here’s a look at where the teams all finished last season. Now forget it completely — it’s a whole new year.
• As always, your thoughts are appreciated. Let’s hear who was left off the list that deserves to be on it and why.
TOP 10
1. Iona Prep — No team returns as much talent as the Gaels, who have their QB, RB, WR all back, as well as a batch of returning stars on defense and along both lines. Their biggest concern will be replacing offensive coordinator D.J. Williams, who moved down south and will no longer call the plays for what has been, in recent years, the area’s most potent offense.
2. New Rochelle — The Huguenots probably had just their second “down” season since 2003 and they still finished just a play or two from a sixth straight championship. They’ll try and start a new streak with a host of skill players back. Their team speed will be paramount, particularly in the defensive backfield. On offense, QB Khalil Edney could continue to ring in a new era after a strong junior year. His presence and a greater number of returning linemen give New Ro the early edge over last year’s champ.
3. North Rockland — The Red Raiders progressed so quickly last season under new coach Tom Lynch. In the process, they reestablished themselves as a Class AA powerhouse. They return a pair of stars in John Dapolito and Nick Connell and will be strong in the backfield and at linebacker. The greatest area of concern is up front. North Rockland will have to mature quickly in the trenches to repeat.
4. Stepinac — The Crusaders lost five Division I players to graduation, including player of the year Austin Taps. They return more than you think, especially on the offensive and defensive lines. The key will be how Ryan Burnett, Justin Thomas, Tarik Stovall and the rest of their skill players adjust to bigger roles and whether or not the defense can stop teams like St. Anthony’s, Iona Prep and Xaverian from putting up big numbers.
5. Harrison — Art Troilo told me this week this team has great balance between its junior and senior classes. It’s reminiscent of the championship teams in 1998-99, 2001-02 and 2005-06, he said, and could even include contributions from a freshman and some sophomores. The backfield is loaded with Mike Amicucci, Jake Marino and Robert Waldman all there around Vin Nicita. Troilo said his biggest fear is the kicking game. In a way, that’s a pretty good sign.
6. John Jay — The two-headed monster of Tyler Keech and Jack Lambert will be one of the section’s best stories. At Carmel camp last month, they two shifted between QB and receiver seamlessly. Keech is more of a thrower and Lambert is more of a runner, but they do enough of each to keep defenses honest, especially behind a good line led by Etnik Rraci and Jason Valvano. So, the concern will be clear: Can the Indians stop people? They’re going to score.
7. Arlington — The Admirals won’t have Parker Howard to hand the ball to this season, but they should have a balanced attack. Right now, Dominick DeMatteo is shuttling between two quarterbacks, but one of his biggest concerns is the depth up front. The starting unit is pretty good. Arlington will be able to say the same thing if that group stays healthy.
8. Poughkeepsie — The Pioneers had so much talent last season. Much of it is gone, but the electric D’Andre Smith should be an excellent replacement for Section 1’s reigning MVP, Josh Oliver. Returning star Brandon Weir will have to lead an inexperienced group up front to clear space for Smith and co. to run.
9. Clarkstown South — The Viking offense relied heavily on three players last year. Two are back in Thomas Lent and QB Ryan McManus, and, with a year of maturation, that should offset the loss of Rockland player of the year Frank Tucek. What’s of greater concern is their strength up front and how they’ll adjust to a much more grueling schedule. South caught people napping last year, but that won’t happen again.
10. Somers — There’s a handful of Class A teams that can compete for a championship this year and could join — or surpass — Somers in the rankings. For now, let’s focus on what the Tuskers have back, namely an elite backfield of Stefano Bicknese and Joe Lombardo, who give opponents decidedly different looks. But who will they run behind? Big Joe Hanley and Chris Groton are among the key linemen who are gone. Yorktown, Rye and Ossining could nip at the heels of teams on this list before long.
Here are the class-by-class rankings with a quick comment on each:
Class AA — Right now, I’d give the top two and edge. Everything else is uncertain, but expect a couple contenders to emerge.
1. New Rochelle
2. North Rockland
3. Arlington
4. Clarkstown South
5. John Jay-East Fishkill
Class A — Watch out for Yorktown. Dropping down to A and returning the Nick MarianotoChristian Dedvukaj could be quite the formula for success.
1. Harrison
2. John Jay
3. Poughkeepsie
4. Somers
5. Yorktown
Class B — Lourdes gets the edge because it has so much back, but Croton will be there in the end. Nanuet could easily join 3-5 on the list.
1. Our Lady of Lourdes
2. Croton-Harmon
3. Irvington
4. Pleasantville
5. Westlake
Class C/D — No team returns the majority of its talent other than Tuckahoe. For now, the defending state champ earn the edge out of respect, but it’s a wide open race in Class C.
1. Dobbs Ferry
2. Bronxville
3. Tuckahoe
4. Woodlands
5. Haldane
Catholics/Privates — It’ll be up to Rye Country Day to reload after last year’s historic seasons.
1. Iona Prep
2. Stepinac
3. Rye Country Day
4. Sacred Heart
5. Hackley

283 Comments
Flyinfrog….The coaches from Lourdes approached my nephew and his friend on 2 separate occasions!!! Just because people pay to go there, doesn’t mean they don’t recruit!!!! Pull your head out of your a**!!!
Arlington would beat Lourdes by 40…even though Lourdes is starting a Pop Warner player ay QB!!!
LOW T, Name one kid on the Lourdes squad who was recruited?
RDI
You’re saying if a qb doesn’t lead his team to a championship he’s not good
Wow’ thats real intelligent, your’e a dumbass!!!
@Loudmouth
Dan Marino never won a Super Bowl so i guess he is no good
@Rotten
what years did you play for artie?
@ RDI
all those power lines at jjef are starting to effect your judgement
Their schedule is so tough because of the way the rediculus system that section 1 has. The previous 2 years, all league ans all section returners, jv schedule. The thing that they forgot was to power rank the wins and losses for the upcoming season!
“Duke is from dutchess and is a great qb already. There are no questions here!!!! Watch his film and tell why he isn’t .. And don’t say because of records…”
ReviewDuke’s tape and tell us why he is not good!!! Doug Williams was on Tampa bay back in the Dayana’s the team was bad but when he went to the redskins he won a super bowl. Did he suck on Tampa bay?????
Case closed!
Just a Fact,
Nobody is saying anybody sucks. But Let’s be realistic here. When he was on Tampa he had no weapons. He goes to Washington to play for one of the alltime great coaches. And did you forget what they had? They had one of the best o lines. HOGS! 4 wr to throw to sanders,clark,didier and monk. And even though he had 1 good year Tim smith at rb. And what about the D it was loaded with talent and speed. I am not to sure if RCK has much talent. Otherwise they would being winning. Last I checked it is a TEAM sport. You can be a coach,teacher,x and o guy but if you don’t have the horses. You don’t win!
@loudmouth—89-91 Graduated 91-92, u?
Just,
You must be one of those guys who batted .400 in little league, but your team was 0-18.
But you were still happy.
I am not saying anyone is good or bad, what I am saying is team goals and team accomplishments are more important than indiv. stats and performance.
Who you rather have a team that goes 2-8 with 1 kid with good stats, or a team that is 8-2 with a bunch of kids who contribute. Case closed.
91 @ Rye we won 6-0 and that game is known as one of the Classics Rye/Harrison game. The game ended on a tackle by Harrison on our 1 yard line and the time ran out for a HHS victory. Rye’s FB caught a pass (Somma) in the flats and HHS CB Vinny Ficarra stepped up and hit Somma back words at the 1 to stop him from scoring, time ran out. It was our 3rd stop inside the 5 yard line in the 4th qtr. The brook never felt so good
ooops backwards haha, i hit submit to fast sometimes
“You can be a coach,teacher,x and o guy but if you don’t have the horses. You don’t win!”
Chuck, that is my point. I seen enough to know Duke is very good – great too strong for now – and this will only be his JR year. RDI is saying the kid is not good because the team is not good. I am saying Duke good but winning will come down to other kids performance on team .. Duke cant do it alone because football the ultimate team sport. I don’t know why RDI doesn’t want to give him his credit. Duke on New Ro would do very very well.. Of course we will take Edney!!!
So again if someone thinks Duke is not good review his tape and tell us why? I know what I saw!
RDI, if I bat .400 and team stinks, it means I am still a very good player right? That is what I am saying about Duke!
Kid deserves the credit he has earned IMO!
“I am not saying anyone is good or bad, what I am saying is team goals and team accomplishments are more important than indiv. stats and performance.”
This I agree with. But for recruiting purposes a kid should be hyped for his individual achievements. Without copy pasting, you said a qb is not good if his team does not win. That just is not true at all!
Just I got ya.
He can throw pretty good but how is he under pressure? He is all about 5 10”. Unless he grows and Keevins get’s away fron the wing t he would go Div III at best. Man I can’t believe how this has blown up on here! Parent makes some bold comments about this incoming 9th grader to Lourdes as the second best qb in Dutchess and BOOM! Maybe we should all move to another position. How about rb,wr? Anyone??
Rotten,
I moved from harrison before hs. cousin Marco A played line in early 90s
Chuck M., when you watch Duke tape he has quick feet, quick set up and quick release. Accurate as well.
Here is his tape. Impressive for Frosh & Soph!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=43Xh5pdlSPM
@ RDI
easy for you to say all this about QBs when JJEF is built to hide a QB more so than any other team in the section.
Chuck m/ just
Duke is by far one of the best qb in section 1!... And he will be the #1 qb in section1 his senior year
@Prince Da most hated and Just a Fact
Agreed….Duke is very good and the Video Doesn’t lie
@loudmouth—Marco was awesome, i know him very well. Biggest guy on the line and the youngest. We had a Senior line with Marco (Junior). we had a very exciting and successful team. Marco was a OT/DT and i was the Center over the rock. This years team has the same scenario, a dominate senior line. Should be a fun season
dutchess fb dad , hudson- val
what are you smoking ??? you make it sound like they are out on a recuiting hunt for players, not true. look at the lourdes roster tell me what kid has not been there as a freshman ???? in the past i would say arlington would have the edge as far as a game goes but not this year lourdes would win , also you cannot compare staffs either lourdes does have the better staff , there is no pedigree there , hudson val- hide a qb ??? wake up , didnt you make a statement about me degrading kids , that is not what i said , or are you classified also ??? thats what you are doing . my comment at the end was i hope they all do well , things can change when pads go on ,lets see
Hud-Valley,
It’s called coaching and running a system.
Well a #3 N.R is better than a team out of the top 10 unfortunately I won’t be in the state of NY on Sept 29th to see the Red Raiders&the Huguenots but I’ll be in Mahopac for the rematch hahahah good luck everyone
FOOTBALL AWESOME
I WILL BE THERE JUST CHECK THE BLOGG!... I WILL GIVE PLAY BY ….#NEW RO GOES UP BY 21 POINTS!!..
Prince the most hated on!!!July 22nd, 2012 at 8:50 pm
Chuck m/ just
Duke is by far one of the best qb in section 1!... And he will be the #1 qb in section1 his senior year
10960July 22nd, 2012 at 9:52 pm
@Prince Da most hated and Just a Fact
Agreed….Duke is very good and the Video Doesn’t lie
10960, Exactly!!!! The tapes do not lie.
And Prince you are right. Fall 2013, this kid will be unbelievable if he is not beaten up too much this year from playing on a bad team!
JUST
THEY GOING TO HAVE TO BE CREATIVE WITH DUKE ROLL HIM OUT TO ISOLATION ROUTES AND FLOOD ROUTE 3 STEP DROP QUICK HITTERS, SOME 2 BACK SPREAD MAX PROTECTION, DBL TIGHT END MAX PROTECTION.. THEY JUST CN’T HAVE HIM JUST DROPPING BACK!! HE WILL NOT MAKE IT TO 2013!!..
Prince, those are some awesome ideas. I think the 3 step quick hitter is under utilized along with ye ole screen!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Great point. He can slice a team up with his arm but they need to find ways to protect him!!
Not sure anyone can catch Soave from Dobbs in the open field or take him down at the line, until someone can stop him Dobbs wins.
[...] So, what better way to bring a level of civility to our discourse than a new Top 10. This, of course, will be the final Top 10 and class-by-class rankings before Week 1 and the slight adjustments are based on my observations and reporting from the preseason. I first ranked the teams in mid-July. [...]
[...] 10 AND CLASS-BY-CLASS RANKINGS • July 13 • Sept. [...]